Bearded Brothers Automation logo

Will a website redesign hurt your SEO?

By Mick Preston, Bearded Brothers Automation · Published
It can, for a while. Google says to expect temporary ranking fluctuation during a site move, and small to medium sites can take a few weeks for most pages to move. Map every old address to a new one, use permanent redirects, and check Search Console after launch.
Coffee shop owner smiling at her phone behind a sunny cafe counter

If you have worked hard to show up in Google, a redesign can feel like a risk. You fix the look of the site and then wonder if the calls will dry up. It is a fair worry.

A redesign can shake your rankings for a while. Much of that risk sits in things you can plan for, and a good plan keeps the shaking small and short.

Everything in this post leans on what Google itself tells site owners. I am not going to promise results Google does not promise. If you are earlier in the process, our guide on whether your small business website needs a redesign is a good place to start.

Will a redesign hurt your Google rankings?

It might, for a while. Google’s guidance on moving a site says to expect temporary fluctuation in site ranking during the move. That means your pages may bounce around in the results before they settle.

How long? For small to medium sites, Google says it can take a few weeks for most pages to move. Larger sites can take longer. Your own site will not follow a calendar exactly, so treat that as a rough guide and not a promise.

The next part is in your hands. Google’s advice for a site with new addresses is practical: map every old address to a new one, send people and search engines to the right place with the right kind of redirect, and tell Google about the new pages. If you do those things, you give your site its best chance of settling quickly. If you skip them, the dip can be deeper and last longer.

Changing only the look is a lighter job. If your pages, your text and your addresses stay the same, Google has less to relearn. The risk grows with every address you change and every page you remove.

Laptop on a sunny desk showing a website traffic chart rising after a redesign
Expect some bouncing in your traffic after launch, then watch for the line to settle.

Why do rankings drop after a redesign?

Google ranks pages, and every page lives at an address. When a redesign changes the address, removes the page, or rewrites the page so it no longer answers the same question, Google has to figure out what happened. While it figures that out, your rankings can wobble.

The usual causes are plain ones:

  • Addresses change and the old ones lead nowhere.
  • Pages that used to rank get merged or deleted.
  • Text that matched what people searched for gets rewritten or trimmed.
  • The new site is slower or harder to use on a phone.
  • Something gets left in a test state that tells Google to stay away.

Most of these are not the design. They are the plumbing behind it. A designer who only talks about looks and never about addresses and redirects is skipping the part that protects your traffic.

If you are sorting out what to hand your designer, our checklist on what to do before you redesign your website covers how to list the pages that matter.

How do you keep your rankings through a redesign?

Google’s documentation gives a short list. None of it is fancy.

First, prepare a map. Google calls it a URL mapping: a list that pairs each old address with its new one. Every old address that matters should point somewhere that makes sense, ideally the page that replaces it.

Second, use the right kind of redirect. Google says server-side permanent redirects have the highest chance of being interpreted correctly by Search. Ask your designer to set these up on the server, not as a patch inside the page.

Third, keep the redirects around. Google says to keep them generally at least 1 year. Longer is fine. Taking them down early can strand anyone still using the old links.

Fourth, tell Google about the new pages. Submitting a sitemap helps Google discover them. A sitemap is just a list of your pages that you hand to Google through Search Console.

Beyond Google’s list, a few common-sense habits help. Keep the text of your best pages close to what it was. Keep the page titles that already work. Test the new site on a phone before launch. If your designer cannot explain how they will handle these, ask again.

What should you check after launch?

Do not launch and walk away. The first days and weeks are when problems show up, and they are cheapest to fix right away.

Open Google Search Console and watch these things:

  • Whether your new pages are being found and added.
  • Whether any of your old addresses show errors.
  • Whether the pages that used to bring in calls still appear for the searches that matter.

Then do a few checks by hand. Click your old addresses from your map and make sure each one lands on the right new page. Fill out your contact form. Call the phone number on the site. Look at the site on your phone.

Also check the boring switches. Make sure the site is set to be found by Google and that nothing from the build stage is still telling search engines to skip it. This one is easy to miss, and it can quietly do real harm.

If you see an old address going nowhere, fix the redirect and keep going. Small repairs early are better than a big cleanup later.

How long until rankings settle?

Google’s answer for small to medium sites is that it can take a few weeks for most pages to move. Some will settle sooner and some later. In the meantime you may see ups and downs, and that is part of the normal pattern Google describes.

If you want to know how this fits into the whole project, our post on how long a website redesign takes covers the stages before launch too. For ranking questions beyond a redesign, our piece on Google Business Profile and local ranking is worth a look.

What counts as a problem? A short wobble is expected. A page that disappears and never comes back, or an old address that shows an error, is not. Those are signs something in the map or the redirects was missed, so go back and check them.

Take your list of top pages tonight and write down the address of each one, so you have a record to compare after launch. If you want help planning the move so your rankings stay as steady as they can, talk to us about a free website review.

Frequently asked questions

Will changing my design alone hurt my SEO?

A new look by itself is not the main risk. The trouble starts when addresses change, pages get removed, or content gets thinned out. If the pages and addresses stay the same, there is much less to go wrong.

How long should I keep redirects in place?

Google says to keep them generally at least 1 year. If you can leave them in place longer, do. They are cheap to keep, and they keep old links and bookmarks working.

What is the biggest SEO mistake in a redesign?

Changing page addresses without telling Google where the old ones went. Without a map from old addresses to new ones and permanent redirects, people and search engines land on dead pages.

More booked appointments. More revenue.

We build the automation that gently turns your website visitors and leads into booked appointments. No chasing, no hard sell. You just show up to more jobs.

Get My Free Booking Plan →

Keep reading

Got a question? Ask Beardy 👋

Beardy

Automated assistant

Powered by Bearded Brothers Automation