Bearded Brothers Automation logo

Does my small business website need a redesign?

By Mick Preston, Bearded Brothers Automation · Published
Your website needs a redesign if it is hard to use on a phone, slow to load, brings in few calls or leads, no longer describes what you sell, or has security problems. If only one or two of those are off, a fix may be enough.
Plant shop owner smiling at her small business website on a tablet in a sunny shop

You built your website a while back, and it has been sitting there ever since. Maybe it still looks fine to you. But you see it every day, and your customers see it for a moment, usually on a phone, usually while they are comparing you with someone else.

That gap is where most owners get stuck. You do not want to spend money on a new site if the old one is fine. You also do not want to keep a site that quietly sends people to your competitor.

This post gives you a few simple checks you can run yourself. By the end you will know whether you are looking at a quick fix or a real redesign, and what to do next.

How do you know your website needs a redesign?

Look at your site the way a stranger would. Grab your phone, forget what you know about your own business, and go through the five checks below. One miss is a fix. Several misses, or a miss on the first or third check, usually means the site is working against you.

Hand holding a phone showing a clean, mobile-friendly small business website in a sunlit shop
Most of your visitors meet your site on a screen this size, so start your checkup here.

Does it work on a phone?

Open your site on your own phone. Can you read the text without pinching and zooming? Can you tap the phone number and the buttons without hitting the wrong thing? Does the menu open and close the way you expect?

This one matters for more than looks. Google uses the mobile version of a site’s content for indexing, according to Google’s mobile-first indexing guidance. If your phone version is a squeezed copy of a desktop page, it is the version Google judges you on.

Is it slow?

Tap a link on your site and count. If you find yourself waiting, so does everyone else, and they have less patience than you do. People do not sit and watch a blank screen. They go back and tap the next result.

Google gives a few targets for a page that feels fast. According to web.dev’s Web Vitals guide, the main content should show up within 2.5 seconds, the page should respond to a tap in 200 milliseconds or less, and things should not jump around while loading, with a layout shift score of 0.1 or lower. You do not need to memorize those. You can run your address through a free speed test and see whether it passes.

Does it bring in calls and leads?

A website is a worker. Ask what it did for you this month. Did anyone call because of it? Did anyone fill out the form? If you honestly cannot say, that is a finding on its own.

Check the basics. Is your phone number at the top of every page? Is there one clear button that says what to do next? Does the contact form actually reach you? A site can look great and still lose every visitor at the last step. If calls are slipping through even when people reach out, the post on the cost of missed calls for home service businesses is worth a read too.

Does it still describe what you sell?

Read your own services page like a new customer. Are the services you offer today on it? Are the ones you dropped still there? Are the photos recent, and is the pricing language, hours and service area right?

An out-of-date site is awkward, and it makes people wonder whether you are still in business, and it sends the wrong kind of calls your way.

Is it secure?

Look at the address bar. If your browser warns that the site is not secure, or you see a padlock with a warning, fix that first. Visitors will back out of a page that warns them, and rightly so.

Also think about the software behind the site. If nobody has updated it in a long time, or you cannot remember who has the login, that is a risk. Old plugins and forgotten accounts are how small sites get hacked.

Do you need a new website or can you fix the one you have?

Here is a simple way to sort it. If the problem is on the surface, fix it. A tired photo, an old phone number, a missing button, a slow image: those are small jobs. The site underneath is fine.

If the problem is in the foundation, you are probably looking at a redesign. That means a site that does not work on a phone at all, a builder you have outgrown, pages that cannot be changed without breaking others, or a structure that no longer matches how your customers look for you.

A good test is this. If you wrote down everything wrong with the site, would a short list of edits fix it, or would you end up touching every page? Short list means fix. Every page means redesign. The full breakdown is in website refresh vs redesign.

Why redesign at all?

Because your website is often the first thing a customer sees, and the first look decides whether they stay. A site that loads quickly, reads well on a phone and makes it easy to call you does a quiet job around the clock. It answers questions while you are on a roof, in a truck or asleep.

A redesign also gives you a chance to clean house. You get to drop the pages nobody reads, say plainly what you do, and make the next step obvious. When it is done well, you spend less time answering the same questions by phone, because the site already answered them.

There is a limit, though. A new look will not fix an offer people do not want or a phone nobody answers. Redesign when the site is the problem, not when it is only the first thing you can change.

How often, and how long does it take?

Both answers depend on your business, and both have their own post. For timing, read how often a small business should redesign its website. For the calendar, read how long a website redesign takes.

The short version is that a site does not have an expiry date. It has a job, and you redesign when it stops doing the job. How long it takes depends a lot on how quickly your words, photos and decisions reach your designer.

How do you start a redesign?

Start with what you already have. You are not starting from zero, and the old site holds clues about what works.

Write down which pages bring in calls, which pages Google shows people, and which content is worth keeping. The post on what to do before redesigning your website walks through that step by step. Then think about search, because moving a site badly can cost you traffic you already earned. Will a website redesign hurt SEO? covers how to avoid that.

Pick up your phone tonight and open your own site the way a customer would, then write down every spot where you got stuck or annoyed. That list is the start of your plan, and it will make any conversation with a designer faster.

If you want a second set of eyes on that list, book a free website review with us and we will tell you straight whether you need a fix or a redesign.

Frequently asked questions

Can I redesign my website myself with a builder like Wix?

Yes, you can, and for a very small site it can work. The catch is time. Layout, wording, photos and setup all land on you, and the result is only as good as the choices you make. If the site has to bring in work, a custom build usually earns its keep.

Will a redesign hurt my Google rankings?

It can, if old pages disappear or addresses change without a plan. Done carefully, with every old page mapped to its new address, you give Google what it needs to carry your rankings over. Plan the move before you build anything.

Is a website redesign still worth it?

It is when the old site is costing you customers. A site that loads fast, reads well on a phone and makes it easy to call you pays for itself. If your current site already does that, you may only need small fixes.

More booked appointments. More revenue.

We build the automation that gently turns your website visitors and leads into booked appointments. No chasing, no hard sell. You just show up to more jobs.

Get My Free Booking Plan →

Keep reading

Got a question? Ask Beardy 👋

Beardy

Automated assistant

Powered by Bearded Brothers Automation